【Farmer’s Wife: Handle with Care! Part 1: Angel Advent (2021)】

As they have Farmer’s Wife: Handle with Care! Part 1: Angel Advent (2021)many times before, tech workers are once again taking a stand against controversial company policies and wishy-washy managerial strategies. This time, employees of decades-old software company Basecamp are quitting in protest of what one employee called a "tantrum" by management.

After a week of controversy that exposed racially insensitive actions that had carried on for years, and what staffers perceived as management's discomfort with addressing them, multiple employees announced on Twitter that they were leaving Basecamp for good.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

On a company chat forum over the past year, employees had reportedly wanted to reckon with a legacy message board, started in 2009, in which sales reps kept track of customers' "funny names." You know, ridiculing an important part of a person's identity. For the lulz.

Long-time tech journalist Casey Newton, who writes the substack Platformer, first exposed the controversy. (In the thread below, DHH refers to company cofounder David Heinemeier Hansson.)

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

According to Newton's reporting, this list was in some ways just juvenile, but it later struck employees as "inappropriate" and "often racist" in its classification of names of Asian or African origin as "funny." Hansson reportedly told Newton that he and CEO Jason Fried had known about the list "for years." But rather than fostering the cultural reckoning employees were asking for, Fried issued a memobanning workers from discussing politics or "societal" issues in company chats at all. (Hansson also issued a memo, lamenting "difficult times" and "terrible tragedies" that ... apparently shouldn't be talked about at work.)

"We all want different somethings," Fried's memo head-scratchingly reads. "Some slightly different, some substantially. Companies, however, must settle the collective difference, pick a point, and navigate towards somewhere, lest they get stuck circling nowhere."

Some employees interpreted this move as the C-suite's way of avoiding internal scrutiny. (It should be noted that Basecamp is an entirely remote company, so online chats are an especially integral part of its work.)

The backlash to the memo came to a head Friday after what Newton described as a "contentious all-hands meeting" when employees announced they were leaving en masse. The meeting became especially heated when one long-term, senior employee said “I strongly disagree we live in a white supremacist culture,” and that taking that stance was "actually racist." Fried failed to immediately condemn the sentiment, which in itself inspired outrage among employees.

The employee has since been suspended. But Newton reports that one third of employees are taking the buyout.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

Many were explicit that they were departing Basecamp because of the new policies. Some were especially scathing, blaming management for mishandling the whole situation. (The tweet below uses Basecamp's former name, 37signals.)

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

Tech companies like Google and Facebook previously championed candid discussions on workplace forums, and the practice has become common among many tech companies. However, discussions around what counts as free speech versus what's just racist, bigoted, or hate speech that violates company policies haven't just waged in the real world and on social networks. They've also proliferated on the internal forums of the companies that build those same networks and other tech tools. That's led to employee protest on both sides of the political aisle and a patchwork of policies surrounding what is and is not appropriate workplace conversation.

Basecamp is the latest example of how tech companies' claims that they are working toward more diverse, equitable and inclusive workplaces sometimes have their limits. Especially when that work means turning a critical eye toward what goes on at the companies themselves.

UPDATE: May 4, 2021, 12:57 p.m. EDT This article has been updated to include more details of the Basecamp all-hands meeting, per a new report from The Verge.